Today will be your last day to work on your essays in class. They will be due on Thursday.
Please let me know if you have questions or concerns and please share what you have with me.
Analyze a motif found in
Macbeth, create a thesis, and connect the motif to the meaning of the play as a
whole by writing a short 2-3 page essay.
Analysis Rubric:
FOCUS
(Claims, set-up)
|
Hook, Thesis Statement, Order of development connects to
an n overarching idea of the novel.
Thesis is manageable. Hook and
thesis are connected by idea. Hook is
witty or insightful.
|
Hook, Thesis Statement are present in the first paragraph
Hook and thesis are connected by idea.
Order of development is present.
|
There is a thesis statement but either it is not clear, or
the order of development and/or hook is missing.
|
No thesis statement
|
Examples and Analysis
|
At least five pieces of evidence from novel. Evidence is either direct quotation or
paraphrases with page # citation.
Commentary explains relationship between evidence and thesis.
|
4-5 pieces of evidence.
Evidence is either direct quotations or paraphrases with page #
citation. Provides commentary on
evidence; however commentary.
Relationship between evidence and thesis may not be thoroughly
developed.
|
3-4 pieces of evidence.
Evidence maybe mere summary w/o connection to the thesis. Or there are vague references to the
text. References could be vaguely
relevant to thesis. Little or no
commentary (analysis).
|
No Analysis or examples or examples are unclear. Repeats information already provide or
simply restates the thesis as evidence.
|
Sophistication of Writing
|
Point of view is evident.
Clear sense of audience. Ideas
are original. Work is engaging. Precise, fresh and original words. Sentence
variety. Effective use of rhetorical
devices such as parallelism or figurative language.
|
A sense of audience.
Conveys ideas to reader. Use of
rhetorical devices. Engaging
vocabulary.
|
Paper lacks energy.
Essay lacks focus and/or doesn’t persuade. Language relies on repetition of the same
words or there is an overuse of “to be” verbs.
|
Voice is not apparent, or doesn’t necessary seem that of
the author.
|
Mechanics
|
One to three small mistakes
|
Three to five small mistakes that do not affect the
reading of the essay
|
Five to ten mistakes
|
Numerous mistakes that impair reading
|
No comments:
Post a Comment